+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

felixmiguelc

Newbie
May 18, 2018
3
0
Mi sister-in-law visitor visa has been refused and one of the reasons seems to be family ties in Canada and in her country of residence. She has all the family there including parents, children and husband and a single sister here. I would like to understand the actual justification behind this argument.
 
Mi sister-in-law visitor visa has been refused and one of the reasons seems to be family ties in Canada and in her country of residence. She has all the family there including parents, children and husband and a single sister here. I would like to understand the actual justification behind this argument.
1. Does she live with her parents and other family members in her country of residence?

2. Did her other family members apply for TRVs? Or were they granted TRVs?

3. How old are her children?
 
Thanks for your reply.
1. In her country of residence she lives with her parents, husband and two children.
2. Her mother has been granted Canadian TVR twice during the last 10 years, including multiple entry visa. She has been refused TVR twice with the same "family ties" justification in top of the not enough funding, even when we (her sister and myself) will be paying for all (we are both Canadian citizens with a family income of more than 100K per year during the last 5 years and enough savings in our accounts). What is interesting is that her mother has been granted TVR under exactly the same financial and family ties circumstances.
3. Children are 4 and 11 years old. Previous TVR refusal (5 years ago) she applied to come alone. This time the purpose of the travel was primary for the kids to enjoy summer vacation in Canada with her aunt and myself. So, this time she applied additional TVR for the children as well.
 
She has been refused TVR twice with the same "family ties" justification in top of the not enough funding, even when we (her sister and myself) will be paying for all (we are both Canadian citizens with a family income of more than 100K per year during the last 5 years and enough savings in our accounts).
Your finances are irrelevant for your sister-in-law's TRV application. As a visitor, she must prove she has personal financial resources to afford the visit plus airfare.


What is interesting is that her mother has been granted TVR under exactly the same financial and family ties circumstances.
That's because parents are likely to be financially dependent on their Canadian children when they visit, whereas siblings/spouses of siblings/nieces and nephews are expected to prove their personal finances for the visit.


3. Children are 4 and 11 years old. Previous TVR refusal (5 years ago) she applied to come alone. This time the purpose of the travel was primary for the kids to enjoy summer vacation in Canada with her aunt and myself. So, this time she applied additional TVR for the children as well.
It's quite clear why your sister-in-law was refused for 'Family ties'. Her mother has a valid TRV/she has visited earlier + as a mother, your sister-in-law's strongest family ties are her minor children (not her husband).... and this time, she applied for her children to travel with her.

That being said, entire families have been granted TRVs simultaneously if each applicant was able to prove his/her individual strong ties + good personal finances without depending on their Canadian hosts.

In the case of your sister-in-law, and based on your post, her financial situation is probably not good enough to support a visit for herself and her two children + she may not have strong ties to her home country.

She must assess her application as a complete package.... and not just the Family Ties and Financial refusal grounds
 
Thanks for your clarification. I can understand better now. Just as a clarification, her mother TVR visa expired two years ago. So her mother has not visited Canada since then. We actually avoided that situation of having additional members of the family with simultaneous TVR. What I do not understand is the same family ties issue under two completely different situations of visa refusal: 1) traveling alone 5 years ago leaving a children at home and 2) traveling with the two children this time. I mean, even considering the application as a package, how can she "solve" the family ties issue, this is not something that you can fix like the financial situation.