Rob_TO said:
I think you are wrong. CIC/CBSA can cancel your COPR anytime up until you actually complete the landing process. There are various reasons that CIC/CBSA could do this.
One of the questions they ask you at landing is if anything in your situation has changed since doing the application. Of course one of the main criteria of getting PR for someone not currently in Canada, is showing intent they will move and settle in Canada immediately after getting PR status. We have seen many cases here of people's PRs being rejected for not showing sufficient proof they will settle, or telling their visa office they intend to settle at a much later date.
Since intent to settle is a criteria to get PR, the CBSA officer can definitely deny your PR landing if they feel you are no longer meeting that criteria. Now for a CBSA officer to do this is probably rare, but as I said we actually saw 1 case of exactly this happening a short time ago. And that is indeed the reason it happened, since he was denied after telling officer his plans to go back home for 1+ year for school/work.
And make no mistake, if the OP had mentioned in his PR app he would not be settling in Canada for full 1 year after getting approval, his PR app would have been rejected
You are not misleading or lying to CBSA at all. By all means say you'll be going home to wrap up a few things if they ask you specifically, but just don't say it will be for 1 full year or longer. They won't press the issue and probably won't even ask in the first place. But I know some people get nervous around CBSA officers and like to get chatty, offering up info they don't really need to. There is ZERO chance this will be used against you in any way in the future, that is just being paranoid.
Yesterday, I have read a case posted on a website of Canadian Immigration Lawyer. It described how CIC refused to give a renewed PR card to someone who came to pick it up per CIC instructions received in mail.
The officer decided to examine applicant at the time of Card pick up (which occurred nearly a year after original application to renew card was submitted) , and determined that
at the time of the pick up of the card the immigrant didn't meet the 2 out of 5 year RO requirement in Canada.
If applicant didn't hire an attorney, he may have lost his PR status. But he hired a lawfirm, lawfirm took case to the Federal Court and the High Court had ordered CIC to mail the man his Perm Res Card (and not ask him to come and pick it up: at the time the case was decided the immigrant was already overseas). High court also ordered CIC to pay $5000 to compensate immigrant for unnecessary burden of hiring a counsel and litigate the case that had no merits to begin with.
So, could CIC officer at the border make a mistake and overstep their authority? As rare as it is, those things can and do happen. I won't deny it.
But I am not sure if CIC at the border had authority to deny landing because an immigrant said he would leave Canada and return a year later, when ready.
It is not up to border officer to rule on the length of time immigrant stays outside of Canada, the lawmaking body decides it. And it is clearly stated in regulations that immigrant can stay up to 3 years outside of Canada after landing, without jeopardizing their status.
Border officer can't make a law, he/she can only enforce what is in the books.
I am not sure if there is a law in the books that says immigrant can't have intention to stay 1 year outside of Canada immediately after landing. Such being the case, what would be the lawful basis to deny landing to someone who wanted to go back and wrap up things before returning to Canada?
And if there is no basis in law, then what is the worst that can happen? A court case, with High Court ordering CIC to correct the error.
However, if immigrant lies (and it will go on record, make no mistake about it), then there are factual grounds to charge with intentional misrepresentation and it's a crime. I would rather be paranoid than do something that would give grounds to charge me with intentional violation of law and impose a ban on my entry for fixed number of years in future.