SINP has been withdrawn!

[anb333]

My brother came to Saskatchewan under SINP and he has PRC. Now we received a letter that CIC has withdrawn nomination, what should we do and is there an appeal process? It was cancelled on the grounds that we relocated to BC. We only left Saskatchewan because I got transferred to BC.(Federal job).

 

[biometrix]

It's because of people like you and your brother that immigration is difficult for others because you want to cheat the system. You got relocated, did your job relocate your brother? Must he b with u? Well you brought hell on yourself so that's that. CIC has the right to withdraw citizenship if they suspect foul play talk less of nomination. He signed an agreement to stay in Sk, why not keep to that? On behalf of cic....you guy got what u deserve!

 

[blue3306]

is there any rule that the PNP nominees must stay that province FOREVER? If not, why cannot this bother relocate to another place to pursue the career even though he was awarded to PR based on the specific PNP? The free flow of labor, materials, and capital is critical for market economy. you know that, CIC knows that.

BTW, how long this bother has lived in SK before moving to BC? Is that the only reason that CIC took the action because of relocation? Some other reasons not mentioned here?

 

[Leon]

He should talk to an immigration lawyer. The PNP's are cracking down on people who go through PNP but never intended to settle in their PNP province but there is no minimum time you must stay in your PNP province, you only sign a document stating that you intend to settle there and I believe the sponsor also signs an agreement stating that he will help the applicant settle in the province and will not sponsor someone he knows does not intend to settle in the province.

I think the key question here is did your brother at the time he landed intend to settle in SK and if yes, what steps did he take to settle in SK, i.e. how long did he stay, did he look for a job etc.

If you had already moved to BC at the time he landed and he never stayed in SK and never intended to, I think he will have a very hard time defending his PR.

On the other hand, if you only knew about your transfer after he landed and he stayed in SK for a few months after landing and tried to look for work before he joined you in BC, I think he has a pretty good case.

Do you know why they checked up on him? Did he land in SK? Did they tell him at the time he landed that they would be checking up on him?

 

[anb333]

It's because of people like you and your brother that immigration is difficult for others because you want to cheat the system. You got relocated, did your job relocate your brother? Must he b with u? Well you brought hell on yourself so that's that. CIC has the right to withdraw citizenship if they suspect foul play talk less of nomination. He signed an agreement to stay in Sk, why not keep to that? On behalf of cic....you guy got what u deserve!

I was transfered by rcmp to bc, he is still in SK and i am not, CIC said that since i sponsored him i should hv been there but i told them its because of my job. How is that fair rcmp is a federal institution.

 

[anb333]

The letter states that the nomination has been withdrawn because i relocated to bc there is no mention of my brother. He was in sk, he is visiting me for christmas and new year.

 

[Arjoolak]

Im sorry and i dont mean to be nosy
But i followed ur old posts and find out ur sister sponsored ur brother case.
We are here to help. But u better say some.
Who is the real sponsor? And is he/she a citizen or only pr?
Is it under family with job or without job?

Ciao

 

[Leon]

The letter states that the nomination has been withdrawn because i relocated to bc there is no mention of my brother. He was in sk, he is visiting me for christmas and new year.

At what point in his processing did you 1) know you were being transferred? and 2) actually move to BC? and 3) at which point did he know about your plans?

Worst case scenario: If you already moved to BC before he landed as a PR and he knew about this, it could be considered misrepresentation as his PR is based on family sponsorship which is no longer there if the sponsor has moved. In that case, it would be hard for him to defend his PR.

Best case scenario: If you had not yet moved at the time he landed and he did not know you were moving, I do not think they can revoke his PR. If he landed in good faith with a sponsor in SK, he did not do anything wrong and all requirements would have been met at the time he landed but he still might have to fight for it.

In between scenario: If you knew you were moving at the time he landed but had not moved yet and he knew or didn't know about your plans which is impossible for immigration to prove, it is really you who didn't fulfil your requirements as a sponsor. You should have let SINP know that you could not help your brother settle in SK as you had stated in your application earlier but if your brother did not know about your plans, that would be a plus point for him.

So yeah, it is not your fault that your work transferred you but you did sign for some sponsorship obligations with SINP and by moving, you are not holding up your end of the bargain.

 

[sabii]

Does the sponsor have to stay in the province of nomination with sponsored personé
i thought once they landed sposnor can relocate to other province :

 

[Leon]

Does the sponsor have to stay in the province of nomination with sponsored personé
i thought once they landed sposnor can relocate to other province :

Until I heard about this case, I would also have believed that the sponsor can relocate to another province after the PR has landed but we have yet to hear what happened in this case. Perhaps this sponsor relocated before the PR landed or CIC believes that he did. Perhaps they are making up new rules that would be overturned in court.

 

[Arjoolak]

Since leon is vip, i dont need to open my mouth but i second him.
Maybe he has moved out before the applicant got in.

 

[sabii]

Until I heard about this case, I would also have believed that the sponsor can relocate to another province after the PR has landed but we have yet to hear what happened in this case. Perhaps this sponsor relocated before the PR landed or CIC believes that he did. Perhaps they are making up new rules that would be overturned in court.

yeah! its possible

 

[sabii]

anb could you please clarify what happened in ur case?

 

[ajibass]

Kindly tow on the side of law court to fight your case. Although, it's 50/50, but you could still get a chance!

We should try not judge people on the forum, no one knows it all, some people might find themselves in a situation like this based on ignorance, all we need to do I to try and see how we could help out not to be castigated them, if you think they don't deserve your help,it's better to just keep mute!

 

[mf4361]

is there any rule that the PNP nominees must stay that province FOREVER? If not, why cannot this bother relocate to another place to pursue the career even though he was awarded to PR based on the specific PNP? The free flow of labor, materials, and capital is critical for market economy. you know that, CIC knows that.

BTW, how long this bother has lived in SK before moving to BC? Is that the only reason that CIC took the action because of relocation? Some other reasons not mentioned here?

See below

My brother came to Saskatchewan under SINP and he has PRC. Now we received a letter that CIC has withdrawn nomination, what should we do and is there an appeal process? It was cancelled on the grounds that we relocated to BC. We only left Saskatchewan because I got transferred to BC.(Federal job).

Did you moved to BC before landing?