scylla said:
Typically when you are entering Canada you want to show proof of ties to your home country to demonstrate that you are a genuine visitor. All of the things you've mentioned (car and belongings are in Canada, return ticket from Canada to US and back) demonstrate strong ties to Canada. So I don't see how they will help.
It's likely that you will be allowed back into Canada since you are visa exempt - but there's no guarantee and always some chance (no matter how small) you could be turned away.
If you want something guaranteed, then your only option is to remain in Canada and forget about the simple visit to the US.
Well i am technically still a visitor at this point, I also have a reason to come back (to finish my year stay for common law relationship and to process the paperwork for PR). So i cant really say i don't have any 'ties' to Canada either when they ask. You made a very good point about the return ticket and having my car still in Canada as valid points that also tie me here. But I also want them to know that i have no intention on staying past my previously granted extension, and that if i am approved to stay longer or receive PR, that i will also follow any guidelines they carry with them.
Any idea what the best way would be going about convincing the officer that I am coming back in order to finish my common law cohabitation period, and that the visit is merely for the purpose of my girlfriend coming to meet my family? I dont think i will run into any problems, as my situation has not changed since the day I got here, I have followed all rules regarding visiting, and im merely wanting to vacation and then return to finish my cohabitation period. The whole situation just has me a bit worried, because we have already purchased tickets to visit for two weeks in march and i have read of a few other accounts of people doing this, I just wanted to clarify that this was possible in my own post.