cantor2537 said:
Police certificates are extremely annoying. My wife lived in China for a couple years after age 18 before immigrating to the US, at which time she needed a police certificate for US immigration. We had to get another one from China when we submitted in August 2011, because the Chinese one was no longer valid even though she has not been back, as well as an FBI check. Luckily for us, after digging through her papers, we found her old Chinese passport (she is now a US citizen) and the citizenship/resident card. We got her cousin to get the police check for us in China. The FBI check and the Chinese check took exactly two months so the police checks came at the same time. I cannot imagine having to do this every three months after your application reaches CPC-M. If they ask, I suppose we could get another FBI check, but it makes no sense to get another Chinese check if she hasn't even been back for 9 years.
Common sense and CIC practices are sometimes dissimilar.
My wife and I are living in China; we were called to an interview in April 2011, but -- after I argued the point -- the Hong Kong consulate agreed that the police certificate submitted in December 2009 was still OK, that a new one was not necessary. This is common sense.
But when a Canadian acquaintance moved to Canada with his Chinese wife (she on a temporary visa), they then applied for PR through Hong Kong, and the wife was forced to get a new police certificate, even though she had not been living in China since submitting the PR application! This is not common sense. Perhaps CIC was worried about her committing cyber crime in Canada but registered in China!? Silly.
Before this, his wife was awarded a temporary visa even though she stated her plan to stay in Canada and apply for PR. This may be considered common sense, depending on your point of view. But when my wife applied for a temporary visa, with a PR application in process, vowing to return to China because her home was in China, and she did would not jeopardize her PR application by overstaying her temporary visa, she was denied. This is not common sense, and inconsistent with the acquaintance's experience.
So, it is difficult and futile to complain about CIC`s inconsistent practices; they seem to be part of the institutional mentality.