Thanks everyone who understand my situation and helping me to sort out this situation . here is few things i hired very famous lawyer during my appeal but he did not do anything for me. now i hire consultant who made my application and send to immigration . i was prepared at this time so there is no reason to refuse my case because they refuse my appeal and told me to reapply. now i have lot of proof for genioun because we are living together from 3 years and within 3 years i have 2 visit canada my daughter also living with is dad from 3 years and studing here so there is no reason to refuse for genioun becasue i am sending lot of proof for genioun . the other issue was after getting divorce in 2006 i dont have contect with my ex husband so when i was filling immigration for my husband that was requirement for arbitration council certificate so i gave application to arbitration and they issue me certificate in 2009 which also show effective date 2009 . now ex husband also file case for wife and he send documents of divorce from nadra certificate which i dont now so he register divorce in 2007 in arbitration council which i dont know and he get certificate from nadra which issue in 2013 so visa officer asking for that why they have different documents from my sponsor . what you guys help me at this point because in Pakistan there is no communication after divorce so i dont know if he register before or not if i know than why my first application refuse and i am suffering this situation from long time also affected my child. so what is good point for me . waiting for your response who is helping me to figure out this situation.