I think its not platform to argue because company are obligated to follow the rules and regulations of government of canada and they are not allowed to provide false informations and noc . So none of the members in this forum can make conclusion.
Not really wanting to prolong this debate and what you say may be true but ultimately it is down to the applicant to show that they have the relevant skills , perform the duties specified and qualifications that map to any NOC code. So the onus is on both parties to not show any misrepresentation and agree only CICs view is important not anyone on a public forum.
Still an interesting debate/precedent that anyone spending a lot of money to become chefs/cooks through a college course need not bother but just work in a KFC or Big Mac not just in Canada but overseas as well deep frying chicken or flipping burgers to gain experience to be classified as a cook. If it works then good luck to anybody who succeeds, ultimately only CIC can say yes.
Like you am sure everyone is interested whether the OP succeeds as that could open a whole load of opportunities for all the 'cooks' out there.