Appeal IAD or Not?

[MUSTAFACAN]

Hi

My wife and 3 kids applied for PRTD from india in September 2017.
I have an online account in CIC website. I have linked my 2 kids application in my account just to check the status.
On July 30 a Refusal letter for my both kids has been sent as message to my online account. It states that they need to appeal within 60 days.

My wife and other kid application is not linked with that account. They don't receive any such letter in the email.
As my wife is Primary applicant I was expecting she will receive email . It almost 50 days since the refusal letter sent to my 2 kids they dint Receive hard copy of the letter nor the passports.

When contacted the consulate they sent a email that they don't have any info as the file is processed in PRC Sydney office.

Now my concern is should I submit the appeal for both kids or not?

Why dint the sent hard copy of the letter and passports?

Why dint they sent any email or letter to primary applicant that is my wife?

The refusal letter is a soft copy without signature of the officer .so I was expecting the paper copy with signature.

I even sent web enquiry but no respons.

Can they refuse kids( below 18 years) application without Primary applicant (Parent)

The letter also states that they are entitled for PRTD as they have been in Canada in last 365 day period.

Thank You

 

[Will_PA]

Hi

My wife and 3 kids applied for PRTD from india in September 2017.
I have an online account in CIC website. I have linked my 2 kids application in my account just to check the status.
On July 30 a Refusal letter for my both kids has been sent as message to my online account. It states that they need to appeal within 60 days.

My wife and other kid application is not linked with that account. They don't receive any such letter in the email.
As my wife is Primary applicant I was expecting she will receive email . It almost 50 days since the refusal letter sent to my 2 kids they dint Receive hard copy of the letter nor the passports.

When contacted the consulate they sent a email that they don't have any info as the file is processed in PRC Sydney office.

Now my concern is should I submit the appeal for both kids or not?

Why dint the sent hard copy of the letter and passports?

Why dint they sent any email or letter to primary applicant that is my wife?

The refusal letter is a soft copy without signature of the officer .so I was expecting the paper copy with signature.

I even sent web enquiry but no respons.

Can they refuse kids( below 18 years) application without Primary applicant (Parent)

The letter also states that they are entitled for PRTD as they have been in Canada in last 365 day period.

Thank You

What was the reason for refusal?

 

[vensak]

Everybody is responsible for his / her own RO - even children. of course in case of children, parents have to sent proof of them being or not being in Canada.
So technically, yes it can be that they will refuse some and accept others (if for example your children were staying with you, while your wife was still in Canada).
However for sure if they did decide on your 2 kids, so the application must have been reviewed and decided for the whole family.
There is no use to wait for the hard copy if you want to appeal you need to go ahead. Your wife shall check her emails and spams to see if she did not receive and email like that (or maybe one is waiting on here account).

 

[MUSTAFACAN]

Everybody is responsible for his / her own RO - even children. of course in case of children, parents have to sent proof of them being or not being in Canada.
So technically, yes it can be that they will refuse some and accept others (if for example your children were staying with you, while your wife was still in Canada).
However for sure if they did decide on your 2 kids, so the application must have been reviewed and decided for the whole family.
There is no use to wait for the hard copy if you want to appeal you need to go ahead. Your wife shall check her emails and spams to see if she did not receive and email like that (or maybe one is waiting on here account).

Thanks for the reply.

I have waited for Hard copy and finally received with PRTD RX- 1 visa. for my all family members.

The refusal letter is dated 31 July but visa was issued on Oct 2.