any CIC MNI reassessment favorable for sponsor ?
I heard that there's a IRB ruling saying that MNI reassessment by CIC should go both ways, upwards (favorable for sponsor) as well as downwards (which is favorable to CIC only)
but i cannot find it. Any expert can help? thanks!
CIC: we cannot do upward reassessments (change a former negative assessment to a positive assessment) since the sponsor must meet the financial requirements throughout the entire process (R133(1)(j))
some lawyer argued below but judge did not render decision in the case i found:
https://www.canlii.org/en/ca/irb/doc/2007/2007canlii72074/2007canlii72074.html?searchUrlHash=AAAAAQAmSW5jb21lIG1heSBvbmx5IGJlIHJlYXNzZXNzZWQgZG93bndhcmQAAAAAAQ&resultIndex=1
Counsel for the appellant submitted that if an immigration officer is able to make a downwards calculation as outlined by the above section, surely an immigration officer should be allowed to make an upward calculation in favor of the appellant. He stated that in doing so, the objectives of the legislation would be served, particularly with respect to section 3(1)(d) of
IRPA that states:
3(1) The objectives of this Act with respect to immigration are
….
(d) to see that families are reunited in Canada;
The second argument from the appellant’s counsel is that if there is a provision in law for the financial calculations in a sponsorship to be downgraded, there must also be a provision for the financial calculations to be upgraded. The
IRP Regulations provide for a negative change in circumstances in section 134(2) which states:
Change in Circumstances – If an officer receives information indicating that the sponsor is no longer able to fulfill the sponsorship undertaking, the Canadian income of the sponsor shall be calculated in accordance with paragraph (1)(c) on the basis of the 12-month period preceding the day the officer receives that information rather than the 12-month period referred to in that paragraph.
[11]